The Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 (PS AS4) and CrossClimate 2 (CC2) are both high-performance all-season tires, but they cater to different driving needs and preferences. Let's compare these two popular Michelin offerings across several key aspects.

Performance

Dry Conditions

The PS AS4 excels in dry conditions, offering superior handling and responsiveness. Its asymmetric tread pattern and Dynamic Response Technology provide exceptional lateral grip and precise steering control. The CC2, while competent, focuses more on versatility than outright dry performance.

Wet Conditions

Both tires perform admirably in wet conditions. The PS AS4 features high levels of silica in its compound, enhancing wet traction. The CC2, with its V-shaped tread pattern, excels in water evacuation, potentially giving it a slight edge in heavy rain or standing water.

Snow and Ice

The CC2 has a clear advantage in winter conditions. It's certified for severe snow service, indicated by the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol. The PS AS4 can handle light snow but isn't designed for severe winter weather.

Comfort and Noise

The CC2 generally offers a quieter and more comfortable ride. Its tread pattern is designed to reduce road noise, making it ideal for daily driving and long trips. The PS AS4, being more performance-oriented, may produce slightly more road noise but still maintains good comfort levels.

Tread Life and Warranty

The CC2 comes with a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty, while the PS AS4 offers a 45,000-mile warranty. This suggests that the CC2 may have a longer tread life, especially for drivers who don't frequently engage in high-performance driving.

Fuel Efficiency

The CC2 typically offers better fuel efficiency due to its lower rolling resistance. This can translate to slightly better range for electric vehicles or improved gas mileage for conventional cars.

Price

The PS AS4 is generally priced higher than the CC2, reflecting its ultra-high-performance design. However, prices can vary based on size and retailer.

Ideal Use Cases

Pilot Sport All Season 4

  • Performance-oriented drivers
  • Sports cars and high-performance vehicles
  • Regions with mild winters
  • Enthusiasts who value dry and wet handling

CrossClimate 2

  • All-weather versatility
  • Comfort-focused drivers
  • Regions with varied weather, including snow
  • Drivers prioritizing fuel efficiency and tread life

Conclusion

Choose the PS AS4 if you prioritize performance and live in an area with mild winters. Opt for the CC2 if you need a versatile tire that can handle a wide range of conditions, including snow, while offering a comfortable ride and potentially better fuel efficiency.

FAQs About Michelin Pilot Sport AS4 vs CrossClimate 2

    • Which tire is better for sports cars?
      The Pilot Sport All Season 4 is generally better suited for sports cars due to its superior dry handling and performance characteristics.
    • Can I use the CrossClimate 2 year-round in snowy areas?
      Yes, the CrossClimate 2 is designed for year-round use, including in areas that experience regular snowfall.
    • Which tire is quieter on the highway?
      The CrossClimate 2 typically offers a quieter ride on highways due to its noise-reducing tread design.
    • Do these tires affect electric vehicle range?
      Both tires are designed with efficiency in mind, but the CrossClimate 2 may offer slightly better range due to lower rolling resistance.